Sunday, November 30, 2008

U of M Wikipedia study

Here is a link to more information about that U of M Wikipedia study I mentioned in class.

Digital democracy

For my final project I am investigating how the digital revolution is and could impact the way government/democracy works. Through my scan of research on the subject, I previously posted three good sources for different perspectives on this issue. Here are two additional sources I plan to use that explore different angles:

A CNN article, written by Craig Newmark of Craig's List, offers a number of examples of how the Internet is changing the way democracy works. In the article he lists examples of what different cities around the country are already doing. This provided some up to date leads for my project.

The second source is an article in The Independent in the UK, which gives some critical voice to the questions we have been exploring in our class, such as: Is more participation really a good thing?

Both of these items provide useful information for my project and hit on topics we have discussed in class.

Thursday, November 27, 2008

Explanatory Journalism:
The Giant Pool of Money

Included in the CJR article "Overload" is the explanation of explanatory journalism as a way for journalism to survive. The concept is as it sounds - explain the news. I mentioned in class they gave as an example a piece on This American Life as an example of this type of journalism at its best. I'm pasting two paragraphs from the article and then am posting the 13-minute piece NPR did on "All Things Considered" that is part of the longer, 56-minute project.

"As it turns out, explanatory journalism may have a promising future in the market for news. On May 9, in partnership with NPR News, This American Life dedicated its hour-long program to explaining the housing crisis. “The Giant Pool of Money” quickly became the most popular episode in the show’s thirteen-year history. CJR praised the piece (in “Boiler Room,” the essay by Dean Starkman in our September/October issue) as “the most comprehensive and insightful look at the system that produced the credit crisis.” And on his blog, PressThink, Jay Rosen, a journalism professor at New York University, wrote that the program was “probably the best work of explanatory journalism I have ever heard.” Rosen went on to note that by helping people understand an issue, explanatory journalism actually creates a market for news. It gives people a reason to tune in. 'There are some stories—and the mortgage crisis is a great example—where until I grasp the whole, I am unable to make sense of any part,” he writes. “Not only am I not a customer for news reports prior to that moment, but the very frequency of the updates alienates me from the providers of those updates because the news stream is adding daily to my feeling of being ill-informed, overwhelmed, out of the loop.'

Rather than simply contributing to the noise of the unending torrent of headlines, sound bites, and snippets, NPR and This American Life took the time to step back, report the issue in depth, and then explain it in a way that illuminated one of the biggest and most complicated stories of the year. As a result of the program’s success, NPR News formed a multimedia team in late August to explain the global economy through a blog and podcast, both of which are called “Planet Money.” And on October 3, This American Life and NPR aired a valuable follow-up episode, “Another Frightening Show About the Economy,” which examined the deepening credit crisis, including how it might have been prevented and Washington’s attempts at a bailout."



You can listen to the entire 56-minute project on This American Life web site.


Word Press

Freebie tips and tricks...

Some of you talked about using this... the home page for this site has some other useful tools as well...

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

News Photographer Magazine Article Discussed in Class

Unfortunately, News Photographer only published this story in the magazine and doesn't see to allow access to it online--even to members. Anyway, I will try to remember to bring it for next week's class. This article was written by the news director herself, Julie Moravchik. If one searches the internet for her name, there are several articles that are listed that are mentioned in the article she wrote. Here is but one example.

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

competent citizens

Can there be such a thing as "too much democracy?" Is there a danger that the digital revolution will give too much power to citizens who aren't competent to use it?

There appears to be a wide range of thought on the topic of shifting political power due to the Internet, from utopian rhetoric to pessimism surrounding the existence of invisible controls and restraints on digital associations.

Within the editorial commentary of Henry Jenkins and David Thorburn found in Democracy and the New Media (Cambridge: MIT press, 2003) the idea is raised that “the pervasive talk about revolutionary change implies that here is some fundamental dissatisfaction with the established order.” Is this really the case?

The perceived danger that citizens who are politically incompetent will yield to much power may be much ado about nothing?

Jenkins and Thorburn are those who argue that the “digital revolution” is actually a “digital evolution” when they assess digital media’s effects upon democratic processes.
“The Web is a billion people on a billion soapboxes all speaking at once. But who is listening?” They discuss the effect that the Internet has upon democracy will be found to first cause changes in cultural forms before electoral politics. “It may take some time to discern the full influence of the Internet on American civic life.” However, the new sense of community and the expansion of “the range of voices that can be heard in a national debate, ensuring that no one voice can speak with unquestioned authority” promotes the creation of a “citizenry less dependent on official voices of expertise and authority.”

Within the same editorial commentary is found the thoughts of journalist Howard Rheingold, promoting the idea that the “virtual community” of online citizens will need to educate themselves in order to properly “leverage” the potential power brought to them by the new media. “The technology will not in itself fulfill that potential: this latent technical power must be used intelligently and deliberately by an informed population…” (The Virtual Community; Homesteading on the Electronic Frontier (Cambridge; MIT Press, 2000)

http://web.mit.edu/transition/subs/demointro.html

http://www.citizenrenaissance.com/the-book/part-one-three-seismic-shifts/chapter-three-the-digital-revolution-and-a-new-democracy/

How Social Media is affecting politics

It's hard to know where we are going if we don't know where we've been. This article takes a look at the 2004 election and compares it to the online social resources that we have now. The article highlights the ease of gaining knowledge and the ability to really get to know a candidate. I think having readily available information not only makes it easier for people to stay informed, but it also makes me want to be informed. If I can, I want to look into motivation for why people stay informed and what drives them to interact with others over politics.

One of my original questions was how politicians are interacting with social media. I found this article that lists members of congress who twitter. It is on a new website that I haven't heard of before, source watch. It is a wikipedia-esque site that "is a collaborative project of the Center for Media and Democracy to produce a directory of the people, organizations and issues shaping the public agenda." While its hard to know who is actually writing the "tweets" it will be interesting to track what they are saying, and who is following them.

Tech President website is a "new group blog that covers how the 2008 presidential candidates are using the web, and vice versa, how content generated by voters is affecting the campaign." The blog started in Jan 07 with several authors with various politcal backgrounds and continues tracking how technology is and will effect the presidency and politics in general. This will be a great source to provide a historical perspective and give some insight of what 'experts' think will happen.

I haven't figured out how this site will help yet (I mostly just find it interesting). Even orange juice is getting involved in the politics game. The tool they have created provides a visual representation of what's being said on twitter and the positive and negative connotations.

A big challenge for this paper will be narrowing down my focus. I think my sources are across the board and one thing that I will need to do in the weeks to come is pare down where I am going and identify what is the most telling.